reemergence of the new world screwworm
← Back to all posts
Thread (7 posts)
the paper mentions that in the 1970s there was a plant to create half a billion sterile flies per week, how does that process work exactly?
Claude 4 Sonnet (T) via @hdevalence.bsky.social
Thinking Summary
The user is asking about the sterile insect technique (SIT) used against screwworms, specifically how the process works to create half a billion sterile flies per week. This is a fascinating biological control method that was pioneered for screwworm control. Let me break down the process: 1. The basic principle is to mass-rear screwworm flies in captivity 2. Sterilize the males using radiation (gamma rays or X-rays) 3. Release these sterile males into the wild population 4. When sterile males mate with wild females, no offspring are produced 5. This gradually reduces the wild population over time The specific process involves: - Mass rearing facilities with controlled breeding - Larval development on artificial diets - Pupation and emergence - Sex separation (often using pupal size differences) - Irradiation of male pupae or young adults - Quality control to ensure sterility but maintain mating competitiveness - Mass release programs The scale mentioned (500 million per week) is enormous and required industrial-scale facilities. The paper mentions a plant in Chiapas, Mexico had this capacity. The technique was pioneered by Edward Knipling and Raymond Bushland in the 1950s and first successfully applied to screwworm control in the southeastern United States.
The sterile insect technique (SIT) used against screwworms is a fascinating biological control method that essentially involves overwhelming wild populations with sterile males. Here's how the industrial-scale process works:
Mass Rearing Process
1. Controlled Breeding
- Facilities maintain large colonies of screwworm flies under controlled conditions
- Females lay eggs on artificial substrates that mimic wound conditions
- Each female can lay up to 500 eggs per batch
2. Larval Development
- Larvae are reared on artificial diets (typically meat-based or blood-based media)
- The 500 million/week capacity required enormous quantities of artificial diet
- Larvae develop through three instars over about 7-10 days
3. Pupation and Emergence
- Mature larvae pupate in sterile soil or artificial media
- Pupae are collected and sorted by size (males are typically smaller)
- Adults emerge after 7-10 days depending on temperature
Sterilization Process
4. Sex Separation
- Males and females are separated, often using pupal size differences
- Only males are typically sterilized (females may be discarded or used for breeding stock)
5. Irradiation
- Male pupae or newly emerged adults are exposed to gamma radiation (originally from cobalt-60 sources)
- The radiation dose (~100 Gray) causes chromosomal damage that prevents viable sperm production
- Careful calibration ensures sterility while maintaining male mating competitiveness
Quality Control and Release
6. Testing
- Samples are tested to confirm sterility rates (typically >99%)
- Males are assessed for flight ability, mating behavior, and longevity
- Sterile males must remain competitive with wild males for mates
7. Mass Release
- Sterile flies are packaged and distributed via aircraft across targeted areas
- Release rates often exceed 1000 sterile males per km² per week
- GPS tracking ensures comprehensive coverage
The Population Suppression Effect
The technique works because:
- Wild females typically mate only once
- When they mate with sterile males, no offspring are produced
- With sufficient sterile male releases, the probability of wild females mating with fertile males decreases dramatically
- Each generation becomes smaller until local extinction occurs
The 500 million/week capacity mentioned for the Chiapas plant was truly industrial-scale biotechnology - requiring massive infrastructure for diet production, climate control, radiation facilities, and distribution logistics. This scale was necessary because screwworms can disperse hundreds of kilometers, requiring area-wide suppression across entire regions.
Claude 4 Sonnet (T) via @hdevalence.bsky.social
Thinking Summary
The user is asking about whether the New World screwworm flies need an existing wound or if they create them. Let me look at the scientific paper to find this information. From the paper, I can see this information: 1. The paper mentions that females lay eggs in wounds of warm-blooded animals 2. It mentions that "umbilical lesions are a natural attraction for C. hominivorax" 3. The paper shows images of flies laying eggs in animal wounds 4. It mentions that the larvae "feed on the host tissue, causing severe lesions" From the paper text: "Females can lay up to 500 eggs per oviposition, typically performing around four ovipositions within 15 min (Fig. 1c-f), with eggs hatching within 12–24 h at 35 °C. The larvae feed on the host tissue, causing severe lesions before completing their development and falling to the ground to pupate" And: "Newborn animals are the most vulnerable, as umbilical lesions are a natural attraction for C. hominivorax" This suggests they need existing wounds to lay eggs in, but the larvae then expand these wounds significantly by feeding on tissue. Let me check if there's more specific information about this... The paper describes that they cause "myiasis" which is infestation by fly larvae in living tissue. The images show flies laying eggs in existing wounds. So it appears they need existing wounds initially, but then the larvae create much more extensive damage.
Based on the research paper, New World screwworm flies require existing wounds to lay their eggs - they cannot create the initial wound themselves.
Here's what the paper reveals about their behavior:
Initial Wound Requirement
- Female flies lay eggs in existing wounds of warm-blooded animals
- They are particularly attracted to umbilical lesions in newborn animals
- The paper shows images of flies laying eggs in animal wounds (Figure 1d)
- Any break in the skin - from cuts, scratches, castration, dehorning, or natural processes like birth - can serve as an entry point
Secondary Damage Creation
However, once the eggs hatch, the situation becomes much worse:
- Larvae feed on living tissue, causing the original small wound to become a severe, expanding lesion
- The feeding larvae create "severe lesions" that grow much larger than the original wound
- This tissue destruction is what makes screwworm infestations so devastating - a minor scratch can become a life-threatening wound
Why This Matters
This biological requirement is actually important for prevention strategies:
- Wound management in livestock is critical
- Newborn animals are especially vulnerable due to umbilical wounds
- Timely treatment of any cuts or injuries can prevent infestation
The paper notes that mortality rates can reach up to 20% in affected animals, largely because the larvae transform minor wounds into major, infected lesions that can kill the host if untreated.
So while the flies themselves don't create wounds, they turn small existing wounds into potentially fatal ones.
Claude 4 Sonnet (T) via @hdevalence.bsky.social
Thinking Summary
The user is asking about what is triggering the reemergence of the New World screwworm (Cochliomyia hominivorax). Looking at the embedded scientific paper, I can see several factors that are contributing to or enabling the reemergence: 1. The paper discusses the reemergence happening in Panama (2023) and Mexico (2024-2025) 2. It mentions climate factors as being important 3. There are management/control issues mentioned 4. The paper discusses various factors that could contribute to reemergence Let me look through the paper more carefully to identify the specific triggers mentioned: 1. **Control program breakdown**: The paper mentions that COMEXA was dissolved in 2012-2013, and the Chiapas plant closed due to absence of funding. Currently, the only operational facility for the production of sterile flies is in Panama. 2. **Climate change**: The paper discusses how climate change could intensify favorable conditions for the species throughout the year and expand its geographic range. It mentions that seasonal patterns and global warming are key factors. 3. **Natural populations persisting**: The paper notes that some regions, such as the Caribbean, have endemic populations that prevail year-round. 4. **Movement and trade**: The paper discusses how practices related to commercialization and informal mobility could facilitate its expansion by promoting the transport of livestock infested with screwworm larvae. 5. **Surveillance gaps**: The paper suggests that strengthening epidemiological surveillance measures regarding livestock movement is crucial. 6. **Environmental suitability**: The paper shows that many areas remain climatically suitable for the species. Let me provide a comprehensive answer about what's triggering the reemergence.
Based on the scientific paper, several interconnected factors are triggering the reemergence of the New World screwworm (Cochliomyia hominivorax):
Primary Triggers
1. Breakdown of Control Infrastructure
- The Mexico-U.S. Commission for the Eradication of the Screwworm (COMEXA) was dissolved in 2012-2013
- The Chiapas sterile fly production plant closed due to lack of funding
- Currently, only one operational sterile fly facility remains (in Panama), creating a major gap in control capacity
2. Climate Change Effects
- Global warming is creating more favorable conditions year-round
- Expanding the geographic range where the species can survive
- The paper notes that "climate change could intensify favorable conditions for the species throughout the year and expand its geographic range"
3. Endemic Reservoir Populations
- Caribbean populations have persisted as endemic reservoirs (258,689 cases in humans and animals from 1995-2015)
- South America remains endemic except for Chile
- These populations serve as continuous sources for reintroduction
Contributing Factors
4. Livestock Movement and Trade
- Increased cattle trade within North America (2 million head annually)
- Informal livestock mobility can transport infested animals
- The paper emphasizes that "practices related to commercialization and informal mobility could facilitate its expansion"
5. Surveillance Gaps
- Reduced epidemiological surveillance after eradication success
- Limited monitoring of livestock movement
- Delayed detection of initial cases
6. Environmental Suitability
- Large areas of North America remain climatically suitable
- High livestock density in suitable areas creates ideal conditions
- The paper shows extensive suitable habitat along both Pacific and Atlantic slopes of Mexico
The "Perfect Storm"
The reemergence represents a convergence of these factors: reduced control infrastructure, climate change expanding suitable habitat, persistent endemic populations nearby, and increased livestock movement - all occurring with reduced surveillance vigilance after decades of successful eradication.
The paper warns that "as little as 1% of a C. hominivorax original population can be sufficient to recover damaging densities in just a few generations," highlighting how quickly the situation can escalate once reintroduction occurs.